Similar to how my scrawling schoolboy script has deteriorated over 25 years of PC word processing, my natural urge to stop and save a game waned. The culprit is the emergence of automatic saving, checkpoints, Xbox Quick Resume, and experiences where the risk feels so great that I can’t help but save constantly just in case disaster strikes. But I’m not perfect. I become complacent. And this week, I was taught a crucial piece of wisdom deep into a session of the newly ported Pokémon FireRed on Nintendo's console: one must always manually hit save.
Many years had gone by since I engaged with one of the 2D Pokémon games — as I skipped the Game Boy Advance, the Johto region games were likely the last mainline Poké-title I played. So I was pumped to pay twenty dollars for a trip down memory lane back to Kanto, and an attempt to catch those classic 151 pocket monsters. I quickly returned to a simpler time. Across several nights, I snagged Caterpie and Weedle, added Pikachu to my team, defeated the first Gym Leader with ease, took a chance on purchasing the Magikarp from the salesman in the Pokémon Center, and journeyed through Mt. Moon without a worry in the world.
The critical error: Not once did I save! The idea simply didn't occur to me.
Jigglypuff will never find love with my Mankey.
The catastrophe occurred on a night when I wasn't even playing… and as my daughter picked up the Switch for a swift 30 minutes of the newer Pokémon title instead, closing my game in the process. As we all know (a fact I foolishly ignored…) starting another application on the console closes your current game. Your progress is only safe when an autosave triggers or after a manual save prior to changing games. Oops.
The Evolution of Game Saves: From Intentional to Invisible
We should regard automatic saving, now so invisible many gamers take it for granted, as a true “cutting-edge” innovation. Although the classic text game Zork implemented a pioneering save systems in gaming, 1986’s The Legend of Zelda is widely hailed as a milestone moment for alleviating the sensation of being utterly defeated after a game over due to cartridge-based saving in NES games. Of course, the onus was still on you to save. (And following a single mistake), you’d never forget. In that decade, save cards for systems including the original PlayStation popularized saving yet still fragile; forgetting to save (or having a card corrupt) meant losing significant playtime. The survival horror series Resident Evil even turned saving into a scarce commodity.
Today's automatic saving, that eroded my manual save habit my FireRed run so completely, became standard around the turn of the millennium. The first Halo pioneered seamless respawn points while Call of Duty honed the approach to smooth difficulty and reduce tedious replay. As the play grew longer — and more open-world — developers solved the puzzle for saving without interruption and, finally, the pinnacle of picking up exactly where you left off.
A Franchise's Adaptation: From Conscious Choice to Unconscious Backup
Funny enough, the Pokémon series offers a clear snapshot of that historical progression. For a long time, the act of saving your Pokémon journey was manual: fans were taught to manually record their data prior to shutting off their handheld console. Starting with Pokémon Sword and Shield for the Nintendo Switch, the series introduced autosave (initially optional), representing a substantial design shift for a franchise known as slowest-changing series.
I can admit failure: A long tenure with Breath of the Wild and modern Mario games utterly weakened my instinct to save. I remain cautious with certain games — I refuse to chance exiting prematurely in a roguelike even knowing it has a robust save system — however, perhaps due to too long since I sank time older game design, or I'm simply pampered, the thought never entered my mind to preserve my progress when I stopped playing. My younger self would have been more diligent to this degree.
The Result: A Discouraged Player
I have not picked up FireRed following the great progress wipe. Upon rebooting the game and discovered my team consisted solely of the beginning Squirtle, a wave of exhaustion hit me. My personal status: Burned.
I might give it another shot… or perhaps I'll remain in the ocean of contemporary releases available now that operate under the assumption I am incapable of manual saving. Still, my affection for classic games remains alive. On occasions when I can convince my daughter away from auto-saving Pokémon Legends: Z-A, we enjoy playing together some retro multiplayer mayhem. Those early SNES games skipped saving altogether opting instead for cryptic character strings. Therefore, if I make a fatal mistake, the setback is minimal. That, at least, is reassuring.